You may have seen the headlines: another national maternity inquiry is underway, this time led by Baroness Valerie Amos. The new Labour government says it will be “rapid” and “national,” a full investigation into safety, culture, and inequalities in maternity and neonatal care across England.
But if you’re getting a sense of déjà vu, you’re not alone.
Because this isn’t the first inquiry. It’s not even the second. And for many women, midwives, and campaigners, the question isn’t what will this inquiry find? but why are we still investigating the same failures we already know about?
Jump to…
The 2022 Shrewsbury Review (Ockenden Review)
Led by maternity expert Donna Ockenden, a five-year investigation (2017–2022) was underatken to examine the cases of 1,592 families. It exposed decades of failings at Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital NHS Trust. The report found nearly 300 babies and multiple mothers died or were severely harmed due to unsafe care, poor communication, and a culture prioritising “normal births” over safety.
The report made 60 urgent actions to improve staffing, training, and accountability. In response, £95 million was ring-fenced for maternity safety, funding now largely removed in 2025 (more on that below).
The 2024 Inquiry: “Listen to mums”
Back in May 2024, the All-Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) on Birth Trauma published its landmark report, Listen to Mums: Ending the Silence Around Birth Trauma. It was co-chaired by Theo Clarke (Conservative) and Rosie Duffield (Labour) and gathered evidence from more than 1,300 women about their experiences of childbirth and postnatal care.
The findings were damning.
The inquiry described maternity services as “chronically understaffed,” said women were being “ignored, dismissed, or gaslit,” and warned that trauma was being normalised within NHS maternity care. From poor pain relief and consent violations to lack of after-care, it painted a picture of a system under strain, and mothers left to pick up the pieces.
Twelve recommendations
The APPG didn’t just diagnose the problem; it offered solutions. It set out 12 recommendations to fix maternity care for good:
- Appoint a Maternity Commissioner reporting directly to the Prime Minister.
- Create a national maternity improvement strategy within six months.
- Guarantee six-week postnatal check-ups focused on the mother’s health.
- Provide specialist pelvic-health and mental-health services in every area.
- Train all maternity staff in informed consent and respectful care.
- Ensure continuity of care, so women see the same team throughout pregnancy and birth.
- Tackle inequalities in outcomes for Black, Asian, and disabled mothers.
- Overhaul the NHS complaints process to make it compassionate and transparent.
- Expand bereavement services for families.
- Include birth-trauma education in antenatal classes.
- Address the workforce crisis, recruiting and retaining midwives and obstetricians.
- Create a national audit of birth trauma to track progress and accountability.
It was a bold, evidence-based roadmap and cross-party MPs agreed that implementing these changes could transform women’s experiences of childbirth in Britain.
Why nothing changed
Despite that cross-party support, the Conservative government under Rishi Sunak did not commit to implementing the recommendations.
There was no Maternity Commissioner. No national strategy. No new funding.
Instead, ministers said they would “consider the findings” while continuing to focus on existing NHS England safety programmes.
And because the 2024 investigation was a parliamentary inquiry, not a formal government inquiry, ministers weren’t legally bound to act on it. APPGs are independent groups of MPs; their reports have moral weight but no statutory power.
In practice, the report was praised, then quietly shelved.

The funding u-turn
Here’s where the story gets even more frustrating.
When the APPG report landed in May 2024, it called for ring-fenced funding, money that could only be spent on improving maternity safety and workforce capacity. At that point, NHS England had £95 million specifically ring-fenced for maternity services in its Service Development Fund (SDF).
But less than a year later, in April 2025, NHS England, under a Labour government, issued new guidance for the 2025–26 financial year. That guidance removed the ring-fence on maternity funding. The £95 million was absorbed into wider NHS budgets, meaning local Integrated Care Boards (ICBs) could spend it on anything they considered a “priority.”
Only £2 million remained protected for maternity safety.
In short: the money that was meant to make births safer could now be used to patch hospital deficits or pay for entirely unrelated services.
The Royal College of Midwives called the move “shocking,” warning that it would “compromise the delivery of safe maternity care in every way.”
The timing couldn’t have been worse. The funding U-turn effectively pulled the rug from under the 2024 inquiry’s recommendations, before any of them had a chance to be implemented.
The 2025 inquiry
Just a few months later, Britain went to the polls. In July 2025, Labour won the general election, and Keir Starmer became Prime Minister.
Within weeks, his Health Secretary Wes Streeting announced a new national maternity and neonatal investigation, to be led by Baroness Valerie Amos.
The new inquiry, he said, would be “rapid, independent and comprehensive.” It would examine the quality of maternity and neonatal services across England, focusing on safety, leadership, culture, and inequalities in outcomes for women of colour and those from deprived areas.
Baroness Amos, a respected crossbench peer, former Cabinet minister and UN diplomat, was chosen to lead the investigation. She has a long record of work in equality, public service and institutional reform, qualities that made her an ideal candidate for a process requiring both authority and empathy.
The investigation will look in depth at 14 NHS trusts, many already known for serious failings, and will deliver its findings by December 2025.

The Leeds inquiry
Alongside the national review, Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust is facing its own independent investigation after repeated safety warnings.
Between 2019 and 2024, at least 56 baby deaths and two maternal deaths at Leeds were deemed potentially preventable. The Care Quality Commission rated its maternity care “inadequate,” citing safety risks and a “blame culture.”
Families campaigned for a standalone inquiry, arguing the national review couldn’t give their cases the scrutiny they deserved. In October 2025, Health Secretary Wes Streeting agreed, launching a dedicated Leeds Maternity Inquiry to run in parallel with the national one.
It will investigate local leadership, culture and accountability, essentially asking how so many warnings were missed for so long.
Why another inquiry?
Critics across the health sector say that instead of acting on the APPG’s clear recommendations, and the earlier Ockenden and Kirkup reviews, the government has chosen to start over yet again.
The official justification is that this new inquiry will provide a national picture, not just a patchwork of local reviews. It will consolidate lessons from previous investigations and pinpoint systemic issues.
But campaigners call it inquiry fatigue.
Every report says the same thing: under-staffed units, ignored women, patchy postnatal care, preventable deaths. What’s missing isn’t data, it’s delivery.
“We don’t need more evidence. We need action,”
— Birth Trauma Association
“The voices of women and families have told us enough.”
— Donna Ockenden, author of the 2022 review
Even the Ockenden review, hailed as a turning point when it was published, hasn’t been fully implemented. Some trusts have made progress, but many of its 60-plus national recommendations are still incomplete.
What an inquiry can (and can’t) do
It’s worth clarifying something the headlines often blur.
The 2024 APPG inquiry was parliamentary, not governmental, which meant it had no formal powers and its recommendations carried moral force only.
The new 2025 investigation is a government-commissioned independent inquiry, led by Baroness Amos under the Department of Health and Social Care. It can access official data, demand evidence from NHS trusts, and issue national recommendations.
But, and this is crucial, no inquiry in the UK is legally binding. Even the most official public inquiries (think Grenfell or Mid Staffordshire) can only recommend change, not enforce it. Implementation still relies on political will, budget allocation, and follow-through.
So while this inquiry carries more authority, it still can’t compel action on its own.
Funding
At the heart of all these inquiries – past, present, and future – lies one issue: money.
Every major report, from Ockenden in 2022 to the Birth Trauma APPG in 2024, has said the same thing. Improving maternity care requires:
- More midwives and obstetricians
- Better postnatal services
- Investment in facilities
- Stable, ring-fenced funding
Without that, even the best recommendations risk gathering dust.
When NHS England lifted the maternity funding ring-fence in April 2025, it effectively gave local systems permission to spend the money elsewhere, at a time when most are running large deficits. Maternity, once again, risks being deprioritised. That’s why campaigners argue that the question isn’t why another inquiry, it’s why no sustained investment.
What needs to happen now
If the new inquiry wants to be more than another report on a shelf, three things must happen:
- Implement what’s already known.
The 12 APPG recommendations and the Ockenden Review actions provide a clear roadmap. Use them. - Re-ring-fence maternity funding.
Restore the £95 million safety fund and guarantee that it can only be spent on maternity and neonatal improvements. - Create accountability that lasts.
Appoint a Maternity Commissioner, as promised in 2024, to monitor progress and report directly to Parliament.
These are not radical ideas. They’re the minimum needed to make childbirth safer and more humane.
Why women deserve better
Every inquiry begins with the same premise: to learn lessons, to make sure it never happens again. But for too many families, those promises are starting to sound hollow.
Behind every statistic is a mother who felt unheard. A midwife who couldn’t do her job safely. A family still grieving.
Another inquiry might uncover more evidence. It might help standardise safety. But unless its recommendations are funded and enforced, the pattern will continue: report, outrage, silence, repeat.
The solutions already exist. They just need funding and political will.
Sources
https://www.gov.uk/government/news/14-nhs-trusts-the-focus-of-national-maternity-investigation
https://www.birthtraumaassociation.org/news-campaigns/birth-trauma-inquiry
Images: Supplied
Birthbabe is supported by the beautiful babes who enjoy our content. We only recommend products used and approved by mamas, however we may receive an affiliate commission.
Birthbabe does not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. The resources on our website are provided for informational purposes only. You should always consult with a healthcare professional regarding any medical diagnoses or treatment options.