“Don’t be too kind, she’ll keep coming back.” Inside the Nottingham maternity scandal

The Nottingham maternity inquiry publishes its findings on 24 June. Here’s what you need to know.

This week, a BBC Panorama investigation revealed details from inside Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust that are difficult to read. We’re sharing them here because Birthbabe believes women deserve to know what has been happening in maternity care in this country – and what is still being fought for.

The Nottingham maternity inquiry is the largest in NHS history. It has been examining care provided to around 2,500 families between 2012 and 2025, looking at stillbirths, neonatal deaths, maternal deaths, and injured babies and mothers. Its final report, led by senior midwife Donna Ockenden, is due to be published on 24 June.

Panorama has spoken to ten midwives who worked at the trust and seen previously unreported internal documents. What they reveal is a culture of poor attitudes, chronic understaffing, and a systemic failure to listen – to women, and to the staff trying to care for them.

What was written on the whiteboard

A 2018 resignation letter from a senior midwife described three letters written on a whiteboard next to the names of heavily pregnant women. FOH: F (a swear word), O (off), and H (home). Not a medical code but rather a crude signal that staff wanted the women to leave.

The same letter described a colleague advising staff on how to handle women who had called the hospital worried they were going into labour: “Don’t be too kind, she’ll keep coming back.”

Sarah Hawkins, whose concerns were repeatedly ignored over six days before her daughter Harriet was stillborn in 2016, responded to hearing about it: “Who writes that in a caring profession?”

A determination to keep women at home for as long as possible is a recurring theme behind many of the poor outcomes in Nottingham. One midwife recalled a woman being told there was no need for her to come in when she called to say she was in labour. When she arrived, her baby had died.

Want to stay up-to-date on all the latest news in maternity care in the UK? Subscribe to Birthbabe Magazine.

A system that failed its staff, too

The midwives Panorama spoke to described what one called “a frightening place to work.” Shifts were frantic. One midwife describes being the only person on shift capable of reading fetal heart rate monitors, running between rooms, fearing someone would die. “Sometimes we’d work all night without food or a loo break. People were exhausted.”

In 2018, senior midwife Sue Brydon sent a letter to management signed by more than 50 staff members. It read: “The single most important factor threatening the wellbeing of families and midwives and the cause of a potential disaster is inadequate staffing.” Management’s response, Brydon told Panorama, was to blame the HR department.

One midwife put it plainly: “You have to be resilient, and to be resilient you have to lower your compassion.” Another described a colleague who had recently experienced a late miscarriage being sent back to the labour ward to deliver babies.

Racism in the unit

Ockenden has already told the trust she has encountered “countless” examples of racist behaviour – staff mimicking accents, non-white women being treated more dismissively. “There was this ongoing thing that South Asian women would complain about pain more,” she said. “But I don’t think it was cultural differences at all, I think it was just discrimination.”

Where things stand now

The trust’s current chief executive, Anthony May, who was not in post when the allegations were made, has acknowledged the failures publicly. “We need to take accountability as an organisation for not always providing the circumstances for safe care, for not always supporting families, for not admitting our mistakes, and for not always supporting our staff.”

The Care Quality Commission has recently moved the trust’s rating from “inadequate” to “requires improvement.”

The Department of Health has said the government is recruiting 2,000 more midwives and investing £149 million in maternity and neonatal care facilities. A separate government-ordered investigation into maternity and neonatal services across England is also expected to report this month.

Why this matters for every birthing person

Nottingham is the largest inquiry. But it is not the only one. Shrewsbury. East Kent. Morecambe Bay. The names have become shorthand for systemic failures that kept repeating, in different trusts, across different years, with the same devastating outcomes.

Donna Ockenden, who also led the Shrewsbury inquiry, told Panorama: “Nottingham thought that there was a Nottingham way, that they were some kind of superior NHS trust compared to others.”

That attitude – the closed culture, the resistance to outside scrutiny, the classification systems designed to keep serious incidents away from regulators – is not unique to Nottingham. And that is the conversation we need to keep having.

The Ockenden report publishes on 24 June. We will be covering it.

If you have been affected by maternity care failures and want to share your experience, you can contact Birthbabe at hello@birthbabe.com.

Image: Supplied

Birthbabe is supported by the beautiful babes who enjoy our content. We only recommend products we genuinely rate. We may receive an affiliate commission.

Birthbabe does not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. The resources on our website are provided for informational purposes only. You should always consult with a healthcare professional regarding any medical diagnoses or treatment options.

Was this helpful? Share the love:

Similar Posts

Birth Academy

Your body. Your baby. See what's coming next.​

Putting mamas first.

Scroll to Top