Why are famous women having to do the government’s job?

Louise Thompson and former MP Theo Clarke’s petition for a maternity commissioner has passed 140,000 signatures – enough to trigger a parliamentary debate. That’s genuinely brilliant news. But there’s a part of this story that’s harder to celebrate: it took two women who nearly died giving birth, while still recovering, to make it happen.

We’re seeing the same pattern play out everywhere. Jesy Nelson, navigating a life-changing diagnosis for her twin girls while providing round-the-clock care, is simultaneously campaigning for Spinal Muscular Atrophy to be included in the newborn heel-prick screening programme – a test that costs approximately £4 per child and is already standard across much of Europe. And midwife Leah Hazard has been pushing for legal limits on midwife working hours, because a system so broken that its workers are pulling 21-hour shifts without proper breaks is not a system keeping anyone safe.

None of these women wanted to become campaigners. They became campaigners because nobody was listening.

But here’s what makes it harder to sit with: it’s not even working. Not properly. Not fast enough.

When the government does listen, it still doesn’t act

Consider what happened when former Conservative MP, Theo Clarke, took her own traumatic birth experience and, rather than simply sharing it, built something from it. In 2024 she and former Labour MP, Rosie Duffield, co-chaired the first ever parliamentary inquiry into birth trauma, gathering over 1,300 written submissions from parents and professionals, which revealed harrowing accounts of traumatic birth and systemic failures across the UK.

They produced a report – Listen to Mums – with twelve clear, costed, actionable recommendations. The headline ask was a Maternity Commissioner reporting directly to the Prime Minister, to hold the whole system to account. The report found that poor care was frequently tolerated as normal, and women were treated as an inconvenience.

The government responded positively. It agreed with the headline recommendation. It announced some welcome measures. And then, a year later, campaigners were still asking when the rest would be implemented.

This is the part that should make us all furious. Theo Clarke didn’t just share her story on Instagram. She, along with Rosie Duffield, built a cross-party parliamentary process, gathered over a thousand families’ testimony, produced rigorous recommendations backed by clinical and economic evidence – and the result is a polite conversation about timelines. Meanwhile, every day, women are giving birth in a system the report itself called broken.

The same is true of the SMA community. Clinicians, academics and patient organisations have spent years making the case for newborn SMA screening in the clearest possible terms. With screening and early treatment, approximately 80% of children with SMA will likely sit and walk independently, against approximately 20% in the current situation – and the approach is projected to save the NHS over £62 million in lifetime costs.

The argument has been made in clinical terms, economic terms, and human terms. The UK continues to fall behind the growing number of European countries already screening for SMA at birth, and every delay means more babies miss the critical window for early treatment.

It took Jesy Nelson’s twins being diagnosed for the petition to hit over 100,000 signatures in 24 hours.

When did tragedy become the entry requirement?

The pattern is consistent, the data exists and the experts have spoken. There have been endless inquiries and reports repeating the same stories. And it is only when someone famous – with a platform large enough to create genuine political discomfort – steps forward that the dial moves even slightly.

There’s something else that doesn’t get said enough: this kind of advocacy is brutal. It means reliving trauma every time someone asks you to tell your story. It means fielding questions from journalists, fielding worse ones from strangers online, doing all of it while you’re supposed to be recovering, or grieving, or simply trying to keep a newborn alive. Louise Thompson and Jesy Nelson are doing this now, while living through some of the hardest experiences of their lives.

They shouldn’t have to. And neither should the women without platforms who are living the same reality, whose experiences are no less valid for the absence of a following.

So yes, let’s sign the petitions. But also be clear about what your signature represents: it is evidence of a government that waits to be embarrassed into action. The women doing this work deserve to be heard without having to bleed for it first. Until that changes, the conversation doesn’t stop.

Want more like this? Read this and more in the Birthbabe Magazine. Subscribe below.

Images: Louise Thompson / Jesy Nelson / Instagram

Birthbabe is supported by the beautiful babes who enjoy our content. We only recommend products we genuinely rate. We may earn an affiliate commission.

Birthbabe does not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. The resources on our website are provided for informational purposes only. You should always consult with a healthcare professional regarding any medical diagnoses or treatment options.

Was this helpful? Share the love:

Similar Posts

Birth Academy

Your body. Your baby. See what's coming next.​

Putting mamas first.

Scroll to Top